In plain language
In a single-center randomized trial of operators during vascular interventions, lighter bismuth-barium composite thyroid collars blocked more measured radiation than standard lead collars (about 91% vs 72%) and were rated more comfortable. Dose was measured, not thyroid disease.
At a glance
- Type of study
- Original research, Randomized trial
- Who was studied
- Interventional radiologists
- Size
- n = 256 thyroid collar measurements (144 procedures)
- Topics
- ThyroidPersonal protective equipmentDosimetry and monitoringMusculoskeletal injury and ergonomics
- Summary based on
- the abstract
What it found
Bilayer barium sulfate-bismuth oxide (XPF) thyroid collars reduced operator thyroid-region dose more than standard 0.5-mm lead-equivalent collars.
Key figures: 90.7% vs 72.4%; adjusted mean difference 17.9% (95% confidence interval (CI): 7.7%, 28.1%; P < .001)
XPF collars were almost half the weight of standard collars.
Key figures: 47.6% lighter; 133 g ± 14 vs 254 g ± 44; P < .001
Operators wearing XPF collars were much more likely to report high comfort.
Key figures: Odds ratio (OR) 7.6 (95% CI: 3.0, 19.2; P < .001) for VAS >90
Patient and procedure characteristics, including fluoroscopy time and dose-area product, did not differ between groups.
Limits to keep in mind
Single-center trial of vascular interventions with dose analysis available in only 117 of 256 data sets; outcome is dosimeter dose rather than health effects, and comfort was self-rated by unblinded operators.
Related research summaries
- Radiation exposure in interventional cardiology: a narrative review of health effects and novel approaches to ensure radiation safety (2025, Narrative review)
- Radiation Protection in Interventional Radiology (2022, Narrative review)
- Estimating effective dose using non-lead protective aprons and a single dosimeter method (2026, Modeling or economic study)
- Radiation Exposure, Training, and Safety in Cardiology (2024, Narrative review)
- Radiation safety: a focus on lead aprons and thyroid shields in interventional pain management (2018, Narrative review)
How this summary was made
ORSIF prepared this summary with AI assistance from the abstract of the paper. A program then checked that the passage supporting each finding appears word for word in that source. A person has not yet reviewed each summary, so read the original before relying on a number. ORSIF summarizes research and does not endorse any product or company. Report a problem with this summary.
Prepared November 5, 2026.